Julie Kulge, Hockey SID at Wisconsin, gave me a copy of this list
back in November when Wisconsin played here.  She researched it.
Note that the totals are as of some point in mid last November.
 
NCAA All-Time winningest goalies
 
1. Gary Kruzich (1983-87), BG                 88
2. Jason Muzzatti (1987-91), MSU              83
3. Bill Pye (1987-91), NMU                    81
4. Norm Foster (1983-87), MSU                 76
5. Robb Stauber (1986-89), Minn.              73
6. Dean Anderson (1984-88), Wisconsin         68
7. Bill Sloan (1952-56), St. Law.             65
  Duane Derksen (1988-  ), Wisconsin         65
9. John Blue (1985-87), Minn.                 64
10. Steve Weeks (1977-80), NMU                61
    Wally Charko (1977-81), BG                61
 
Justin Doherty, Northern Michigan