The West All-American (selected by Division I West coaches):
 
Goalie:      Darrin Madeley     Lake Superior State
Defensemen:  Mark Astley        Lake Superior State
             Joby Messier       Michigan State
Forwards:    Dallas Drake       Northern Michigan
             Dwayne Norris      Michigan State
             Denny Felsner      Michigan
 
Taken from Lansing State Journal (article by Neil Koepke) which said
that the second team was exclusively from the WCHA, but did not give
the names.