Here's my last visit of this old dog for those whose hearts are set on
seeing full and accurate results.
First, a summary of "Blanket Oppositions" volunteered, like "anyone
playing against...", "I hate...", "I can't cheer for...", or "I don't
support megaprograms like...".
Then an updated version of the original summary, correcting my slights
of Sara and Tony and adding a few non-Div I mentions and votes of
latecomers and avowed tie-breakers. It's final because I don't deserve
another chance to get it right and trying to pull the Big Red even with
RPI only made more Engineers mad.
BTW, the original question that launched this avalanche was whether
there seems to be a disproportionately high representation on Hockey-L
by those ECAC nerds. Hokey as this survey is, we sure got the goods on
'em, eh? Cornell and RPI combined account for 20-25%.
BLANKET OPPOSITIONS:
6 Michigan ("the leaders and...") - Jim Dixon; Nicholas Demet; Jeff
Partnow; Rick McAdoo; Tim Hale; Jeff Jackson;
4 Minnesota - Nathan Hampton; Matt Bigley; Nicholas Demet; Rick McAdoo
2 Maine - Josh Gibney; Troy Taylor;
2 New Hampshire - Deron Treadwell; Matt Bigley
2 RPI - Andy Weise; Jim Teresco;
1 Anyone near Union in the standings - Jim Teresco
1 Boston Col - Ken Kretsch
1 Boston Univ - Deron Treadwell
1 Cornell - Erik Phelps
1 Lake Superior St - Sara Fagan
1 Michigan State - Rick McAdoo
1 Ohio State - Rick McAdoo
1 St Lawrence - Erik Phelps
1 Wisconsin - Rick McAdoo
REWORK OF ORIGINAL ALLEGIANCE RESULTS:
Method A ("Unallocated") - each team favorably mentioned gets one full
point, regardless of how many schools were mentioned by a single
respondent. So, there are more total points than respondents. If
someone mentioned five schools, there are five points contributed by
his/her response.
Method B ("Allocated") - each respondent gets only one point to split
between schools with Div I hockey programs, divided equally since
(unfortunately) the respondent wasn't asked for weights. So, from a
response that mentions "RPI, Boston U, North Dakota and Fresno State",
Division I hockey schools RPI, BU and UND each get 0.33 points. In the
"Other Allegiances" tabulation, Fresno State gets 0.25 points.
[The list server will kill my fixed font formatting, but you can hit
"Reply" and reformat that to fixed font to read]
HOCKEY-L RESPONSES:
Respondents 108.00
Division I teams represented 42.00
Others mentioned 28.00
METHOD A METHOD B
"Unallocated" "Allocated"
DIVISION I CONFERENCE ALLEGIANCES:
AH 6 3.8% 2.62 2.4%
CCHA 23 14.5% 16.28 15.2%
CHA 3 1.9% 2.20 2.1%
ECAC 64 40.3% 44.52 41.6%
HE 37 23.3% 23.08 21.6%
WCHA 26 16.4% 18.30 17.1%
TOTAL DIV I 159 100.0% 107.00 100.0%
OTHER ALLEGIANCES:
NonD1 31 - 10.68 -
DIVISION I TEAM ALLEGIANCES:
AH Army 1 0.6% 1.00 0.9%
AH Bentley 3 1.9% 0.87 0.8%
AH Connecticut 1 0.6% 0.50 0.5%
AH Holy Cross 1 0.6% 0.25 0.2%
CCHA Al-Fairbanks 3 1.9% 1.67 1.6%
CCHA Lk Superior 2 1.3% 0.70 0.7%
CCHA Miami 1 0.6% 1.00 0.9%
CCHA Michigan 6 3.8% 4.33 4.0%
CCHA Mich State 8 5.0% 6.08 5.7%
CCHA Neb-Omaha 1 0.6% 0.50 0.5%
CCHA N Michigan 1 0.6% 1.00 0.9%
CCHA Notre Dame 1 0.6% 1.00 0.9%
CHA Air Force 1 0.6% 0.20 0.2%
CHA Ala-Huntsville 1 0.6% 1.00 0.9%
CHA Bemidji State 1 0.6% 1.00 0.9%
ECAC Brown 4 2.5% 3.33 3.1%
ECAC Clarkson 9 5.7% 6.83 6.4%
ECAC Colgate 2 1.3% 0.67 0.6%
ECAC Cornell 15 9.4% 12.53 11.7%
ECAC Dartmouth 1 0.6% 0.50 0.5%
ECAC Harvard 5 3.1% 2.12 2.0%
ECAC Princeton 3 1.9% 1.08 1.0%
ECAC Rensselaer 16 10.1% 12.92 12.1%
ECAC St. Lawrence 2 1.3% 0.83 0.8%
ECAC Union 4 2.5% 2.83 2.6%
ECAC Vermont 3 1.9% 0.87 0.8%
HE Boston Col 3 1.9% 0.87 0.8%
HE Boston U 3 1.9% 1.53 1.4%
HE Maine 13 8.2% 9.78 9.1%
HE Mass.-Lowell 3 1.9% 2.50 2.3%
HE Massachusetts 2 1.3% 0.83 0.8%
HE Merrimack 1 0.6% 0.50 0.5%
HE New Hampshire 9 5.7% 5.62 5.2%
HE Northeastern 3 1.9% 1.45 1.4%
WCHA Col College 2 1.3% 0.70 0.7%
WCHA Michigan Tech 4 2.5% 3.50 3.3%
WCHA Minnesota 9 5.7% 6.73 6.3%
WCHA Minn-Duluth 3 1.9% 1.03 1.0%
WCHA North Dakota 2 1.3% 1.50 1.4%
WCHA St. Cloud 1 0.6% 0.50 0.5%
WCHA WCHA Generic 1 0.6% 1.00 0.9%
WCHA Wisconsin 4 2.5% 3.33 3.1%
TOT DIV I 159 100.0% 107.00 100.0%
OTHER ALLEGIANCES:
Bowdoin 1 0.5% 0.11 0.1%
Bryn Mawr 1 0.5% 0.50 0.5%
California 1 0.5% 0.20 0.2%
Charlestown Chiefs 2 1.1% 1.50 1.4%
Colby 1 0.5% 0.11 0.1%
Colorado 1 0.5% 0.20 0.2%
Elmira College 1 0.5% 0.50 0.5%
Illinois-Urbana 1 0.5% 0.50 0.5%
Indiana U (Penn) 1 0.5% 0.33 0.3%
Kentucky 3 1.6% 1.33 1.2%
MIT 1 0.5% 0.14 0.1%
Mount Ida 1 0.5% 0.50 0.5%
Mt. Holyoke 1 0.5% 0.20 0.2%
New England Col 1 0.5% 0.11 0.1%
Penn State 1 0.5% 0.25 0.2%
Purdue 1 0.5% 0.33 0.3%
San Jose State 1 0.5% 0.50 0.5%
Satellite TV 1 0.5% 0.11 0.1%
Schlittschuhclub Bern1 0.5% 0.33 0.3%
Southern Cal 1 0.5% 0.50 0.5%
Trinity College 1 0.5% 0.33 0.3%
U Illinois
- Urb/Champaign 1 0.5% 0.50 0.5%
U. Rochester 1 0.5% 0.50 0.5%
UC Riverside 1 0.5% 0.20 0.2%
UC Santa Barbara 1 0.5% 0.20 0.2%
Umass-Boston 1 0.5% 0.20 0.2%
Utah 1 0.5% 0.33 0.3%
Wentworth 1 0.5% 0.14 0.1%
TOTAL OTHER 31 16.3% 10.68 9.9%
TOTAL ALLEGIANCES 190 100.0% 108.00 100.0%
WHO SAID WHAT:
Factors by names represent their fractional point allocations under
Method B (only those who mentioned more than one team).
ATLANTIC HOCKEY:
Army Daryl Chamberlain;
Bentley Linda Harrison (0.33); Thom Davis (0.33); Rick McAdoo (0.20);
Connecticut Billy G. Taylor (0.50);
Holy Cross Bob Saunders (0.25);
CCHA:
Alaska-Fairbanks Jim Dixon; Jeff Partnow (0.33); Brian Morris (0.33);
Lake Superior Chuck Cliff (0.50); Bob Woodbury (0.20);
Miami Bob Hamilton;
Michigan Bob Griebel; Arik Marks (0.33); Dave Chamberlain; Greg
Bryden (0.50); Diane Hatfield; Anne Baseler (0.50);
Michigan State Ellen Kay Closs; Jeff Jackson; Fred Hasselback;
Nathan Hampton (0.50); Glen Keeney; Nate Ewell (0.25); Mike Stock; Bill
& Virginia (0.33);
Nebraska-Omaha Ben Flickinger (0.50);
Northern Michigan Tim McIntosh;
Notre Dame Patrick E. Fleming;
CHA:
Air Force Charlie Shub (0.20);
Alabama-Huntsville T. N. Long;
Bemidji State Troy Mills;
ECAC:
Brown Thomas Chestna; Bill Corrigan; Jeff Partnow (0.33); Kevin Grau;
Clarkson Tod Nielson; Michael Rose; Chuck Cliff (0.50); Joe LaCour
(0.50); Erik Phelps; Laura Phelps; Andy Weise (0.50); Timothy J King;
Sara Fagan (0.33);
Colgate Brian Morris (0.33); Sara Fagan (0.33);
Cornell Arik Marks (0.33); Matt Sparling; Charlie Shub (0.20);
William Ching-Yun Devine; Greg Bryden (0.50); John Whelan; Patrick Carr;
Dianne Miller; Sonja Watkins Kelly; Anne Baseler (0.50); Bill Fenwick;
Rich Hovorka; William Sangrey; Monica Hui; Rita-Ann Mon
Dartmouth Ben Flickinger (0.50);
Harvard Sean Keller; Bob Saunders (0.25); Jeff Partnow (0.33); Linda
Harrison (0.33); Rick McAdoo (0.20);
Princeton Ken Kretsch (0.33); Nate Ewell (0.25); Daniel McMurrer (0.50);
Rensselaer Joe Makowiec; Billy G. Taylor (0.50); Ralph Baer; Eric
Maiwald; Nicholas Markham; John Crow; Andy B.; Bob Saunders (0.25);
Brian Morris (0.33); Andy Mondore; Mark Lewin; Bob Stagat; Matt
Calderwood (0.50); Tony Buffa; Andy Loggia; Bill & Virginia (0.33);
St. Lawrence Joe LaCour (0.50); Sara Fagan (0.33);
Union Andy Weise (0.50); Jim Teresco; Hornick; Bill & Virginia (0.33);
Vermont Arik Marks (0.33); Charlie Shub (0.20); Ken Kretsch (0.33);
HOCKEY EAST:
Boston College Cathryn Spreeman (0.33); Linda Harrison (0.33); Rick
McAdoo (0.20);
Boston University Ken Kretsch (0.33); Ed Moller; Rick McAdoo (0.20);
Maine Jerry Barrows; Robert Eaton; D Wollstadt; Wayne Smith; Jan and
Woody; Deron Treadwell; Matt Bigley; Holly Robinson; Nate Ewell (0.25);
Thom Davis (0.33); Bob Woodbury (0.20); Matt Calderwood (0.50); Wilfred
Doiron (0.50);
Mass.-Lowell S.J.Bongiorno (0.50); Scott Kaplan; Dave Hatfield;
Massachusetts Cathryn Spreeman (0.33); Daniel McMurrer (0.50);
Merrimack S.J.Bongiorno (0.50);
New Hampshire Cathryn Spreeman (0.33); Josh Gibney; Troy Taylor; Ben
Sylvain; Nate Ewell (0.25); Thom Davis (0.33); Bob Woodbury (0.20);
Craig and Terry Knowles; Wilfred Doiron (0.50);
Northeastern Craig Powers; Bob Saunders (0.25); Rick McAdoo (0.20);
WCHA:
Colorado College Charlie Shub (0.20); Tim Hale (0.50);
Michigan Tech Bob Gilreath; Bob Gilreath's freshman son; Tim Hale
(0.50); Garrett Lanzy;
Minnesota Charlie Shub (0.20); Carol White; Martin Kline; Dave
Geringer; Indy Rutks (0.33); Pat Gonzales; Doug Peterson; Bob Woodbury
(0.20); Erik Biever;
Minnesota-Duluth Matt Sullivan (0.50); Indy Rutks (0.33); Bob
Woodbury (0.20);
North Dakota Nancy A Holter; Matt Sullivan (0.50);
St. Cloud Nathan Hampton (0.50);
WCHA Generic Rosi DeBacker;
Wisconsin Jay Punwar; Indy Rutks (0.33); Tom McArdle; Nicholas Demet;
OTHER ALLEGIANCES:
Bowdoin Bob Woodbury (0.11);
Bryn Mawr Bob Griebel (0.50);
California Nathan Hampton (0.20);
Charlestown Chiefs Dan Doucette; Erik Biever (0.50);
Colby Bob Woodbury (0.11);
Colorado Thom Davis (0.20);
Elmira College Bill Fenwick (0.50);
Illinois-Urbana Tony Buffa (0.50);
Indiana U. of PA Pat Gonzales (0.33);
Kentucky Tom McArdle (0.50); Pat Gonzales (0.33); T. N. Long (0.50);
MIT Rick McAdoo (0.14);
Mount Ida College Ed Moller (0.50);
Mt. Holyoke Thom Davis (0.20);
New England College Bob Woodbury (0.11);
Penn State Sara Fagan (0.25);
Purdue Rita-Ann Monde (0.33);
San Jose State Patrick E. Fleming (0.50);
Satellite TV Bob Woodbury (0.11);
Schlittschuhclub Bern John Whelan (0.33);
Southern Cal Bob Hamilton (0.50);
Trinity College Rita-Ann Monde (0.33);
U. Illinois - Urbana/Champaign Dianne Miller (0.50);
U. Rochester Rich Hovorka (0.50);
UC Riverside Nathan Hampton (0.20);
UC Santa Barbara Nathan Hampton (0.20);
UMass-Boston Bob Saunders (0.20);
Utah John Whelan (0.33);
Wentworth Rick McAdoo (0.14);
And that's final,
Bob
We need an issue to get the focus
off the Michigan fight song. Let's
attack gay marriages.
|
